Alzheimer’s and the Amyloid Hypothesis
Alzheimer’s disease is a progressive brain disorder hypothesized to be caused by amyloid deposits between neurons and abnormal accumulations of tau protein that form twisted threads called neurofibrillary tangles that collect inside neurons.9 This causes the brain to shrink and brain cells to eventually die. The loss of synaptic connections, reduction in glucose, and energy production within the brain lead to impaired memory, altered thinking processes, and changes in behavior and social skills – and possibly also include a reduction in neurogenesis.
Not surprisingly, these changes affect a person’s ability to function. The processes essential for brain health – cellular communication, metabolism, repair, remodeling, and regeneration – are disrupted, or deteriorate, in people with brain disorders. For example, an early loss of synaptic connections is characteristic in Alzheimer’s-related cognitive decline.10
Within the Alzheimer’s research community there have been two views on the amyloid hypothesis, which asserts “that abnormal accumulation and aggregation of β‑amyloid (Aβ) peptides (the main component of amyloid plaques) play a key role in triggering a cascade of pathological events that lead to the clinical syndrome of Alzheimer’s disease dementia.”11
- Opponents believe that amyloid deposition is not the direct cause of Alzheimer’s, and that the true reason remains unknown. In Alzheimer’s disease there is a complex relationship between amyloid pathology, neurological degeneration, and dementia. Comparative postmortem to living studies of axonal loss show that the severity of resulting cognitive impairment does not correlate well to the amount or distribution of amyloid plaque. This leads to the questioning of the validity of targeting amyloid for removal in symptomatic disease. In addition, there have been many clinical trials of anti-amyloid therapies for mild to moderate Alzheimer’s dementia over the past two decades that have failed – thus creating skepticism of the amyloid hypothesis in general.
- Adherents to the amyloid hypothesis think that a key role in triggering the Alzheimer’s dementia symptoms are caused by abnormal accumulation and aggregation of amyloid plaques. There is strong evidence by way of human genetics data, biochemical, histological, and animal model evidence that point to amyloid accumulation as a critical player in Alzheimer’s disease. There can be up to 15 years of lead time where brain amyloid can be detected prior to the onset of reduced cognition of Alzheimer’s. Elevated amyloid is also associated with a substantially increased risk of developing Alzheimer’s dementia in the ensuing decade, which supports the concept of a long asymptomatic stage of Alzheimer’s. Thus, for prevention of clinical disease removing amyloid is generally considered a highly promising target.
Revival of the Anti-Amyloid Strategy
As detailed in a recent journal article, two major advances revived the anti-amyloid strategy for symptomatic Alzheimer’s:12
- “Development of accurate human biomarkers…that can detect the presence of amyloid plaques and tau pathology in the brain in both preclinical and symptomatic Alzheimer’s disease.” These include PET imaging, cerebrospinal fluid analysis, and emerging blood tests for beta-amyloid and tau measurements. These new biomarkers permit evaluation for initial treatment, clinical trials, monitoring of patients, and are useful for evaluating target endpoints for amyloid/tau removal in patients undergoing treatment. At the Alzheimer’s Association International Conference held in July 2024, a large study on the result for the blood test PrecivityAD2 showed that it was 90% accurate at identifying Alzheimer’s disease, compared to 63% and 73% diagnosis accuracy by primary care physicians and memory care clinics respectively.13
- “Development of a new generation of Anti-Amyloid Antibody Treatments that target aggregated forms of beta-amyloid… and all robustly reduce the burden of existing amyloid plaques in the human brain.”
Anti-Amyloid Antibody Treatments
Lecanemab (Leqembi®), which received traditional FDA approval July 2023, was the first monoclonal antibody therapy to target and remove beta-amyloid from the brain.14 Donanemab (Kisunla™), also a monoclonal antibody, was approved in July 2024.15 Both therapies are administered by intravenous infusion and are indicated to treat early Alzheimer’s disease, specifically people living with MCI or mild dementia due to Alzheimer’s disease who have confirmation of elevated beta-amyloid in the brain.16
Both Leqembi and Kisunla drugs are anti-amyloids, proteins engineered to adhere to and identify beta-amyloids, a biomarker associated with Alzheimer’s disease. Immune cells then target the identified amyloid for destruction. While both drugs are anti-amyloids, each works differently to slow disease progression: “Leqembi targets small chains of linked‑up beta-amyloid proteins called protofibrils. By preventing these protofibrils from emerging, the drug prevents amyloid plaques from forming. In addition, it also targets amyloid plaques. Meanwhile, Kisunla only targets the beta-amyloid plaques.”17
The drugs are further differentiated by their administration protocols: Although each requires intravenous infusion at medical facilities, Leqembi is meant to be administered biweekly for an indefinite period and is bodyweight dose dependent, whereas the Kisunla protocol dictates monthly infusions during the initial treatment period. Unlike Leqembi, Kisunla is not bodyweight dose dependent, and it is meant to be discontinued when target reduction end points of brain amyloid deposits are achieved (measured by PET scans during treatment period).
In May 2024, Eisai submitted for FDA approval a subcutaneous injectable form of Leqembi; if the autoinjector is approved, patients would have the convenience of using at home whilst still having the option for continued care at a medical facility.18
It is important to note that Kisunla and Leqembi are designed to slow the progression of Alzheimer’s disease in early-stage patients; neither is a cure, and neither can reverse or repair existing damage in the brain.
In a Kisunla research study, deterioration in thinking and memory were slowed 4.5 to 7.5 months when compared to the placebo group.19 The best clinical response was in those younger than age 75, with lesser symptoms and brain amyloid buildup.
Like all medications, taking either of these drugs comes with risks. Those undergoing treatment with Leqembi or Kisunla need to be regularly monitored for side effects, including infusion-related reactions, allergic reactions, brain swelling, or brain bleeds known as amyloid-related imaging abnormalities (ARIA).20
Costs
In the U.S., for a person of average weight, one year of Leqembi costs $26,500; Kisunla, which doesn’t factor body weight in dosing, costs $32,000 annually. Patients receiving Kisunla treatment can stop taking the drug when their beta-amyloid is cleared to a predetermined level, thereby potentially reducing overall costs. Duration of treatment with Kisunla varies by individual, with research studies showing ranges of 6‑18 months.21
Diagnostic PET scans, ongoing brain scans, and additional medical care to monitor patients or treat side effects add considerable expense over and above the cost of the actual drugs.
Marketing and Healthcare Coverage Approvals
Subsequent to their FDA approvals in the U.S., both Leqembi and Kisunla and supporting care costs are covered by Medicare Part B under a National Coverage Determination – the patient has to have a diagnosis of MCI or mild Alzheimer’s disease, documented evidence of beta-amyloid plaques in the brain, and have a physician and appropriate clinical team who will participate in a qualifying registry to gather data on the medical status of patient as they undergo treatment.22
The injectable form of Leqembi being reviewed by the FDA is intended to be self-administered, and as such will not fall under Medicare Part B, but would be covered under a prescription plan/Medicare part D.23
Along with Medicare, the Veteran’s Administration and some larger insurers will cover Leqembi, but some insurance companies have chosen to exclude it, considering it an experimental treatment.24
Leqembi is approved for use in the U.K., China, South Korea, Israel, Hong Kong, and Japan. The U.K. approval came with conditional support: Leqembi will not be covered for patients seeking treatment through the National Health Service due to concerns over efficacy and safety.25 The European Medicines Agency refused to grant a marketing authorization for similar reasons.26 Other countries are expected to make decisions on approval for both Leqembi and Kisunla in the future.
Slow Uptake of Anti-amyloid Treatment in Marketplace
Despite its initial projections that 10,000 patients would be taking Leqembi by March 2024, Leqembi’s maker, Japan’s Eisai, modified their projections while noting that sales are increasing.27
Some of the hurdles facing more widespread treatment include:
- Medical experts’ skepticism over the anti-amyloid hypothesis and concerns over side effects and cost-benefit of treatment.
- Difficulties in identifying suitable patients and initiating treatment before advancing cognitive decline.
- Patient population limitations due to contraindicated conditions or medications (e.g., anti-coagulation / blood thinners).
- Difficulties securing the care of a neurologist for diagnosis and administration of drug.
- Hospitals and health systems have longer-than-expected periods to set up the infusion and supporting care protocols. Some treatment centers have limited patients to a narrow geographical radius in order to have ready access to patients in the eventuality of complications.
- Health systems are still trying to understand how coverage for the drug and supporting care will be administered so patients are not overwhelmed with high costs.
Outlook
The two drugs discussed were successful in garnering FDA approval after development and meeting target results in clinical trials. As of early 2024, there were approximately 134 drugs in various stages of clinical trials, and 171 ongoing studies – all targeting MCI and early Alzheimer’s.28 This is a rapidly emerging sector, and we look forward to the development of increasingly effective treatments in the future.